The Welpr Rating is determined by a scoring formula. The formula takes into account the products safety, user satisfaction, and eco-ethical standing. Click here to learn more.
Best Non-Toxic Pie Pans in 2024
Updated:
Nov 18, 2024
Written by Camille May
Cofounder & Product Curator
+ 1 more
Medically reviewed by Olushola Awoyemi
PhD Environmental Toxicology
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Our use of affiliate links does not influence how we rate products. Learn more about our affiliate policy here.
What you should know when choosing non-toxic pie pans on Welpr:
- Only the cleanest products make it onto Welpr.
- We use a score called the Welpr Rating to rank each product.
- The Welpr Rating is based on math, not opinion, ensuring it's free from human bias.
SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS
Find Non-Toxic Pie Pans
Xtrema - Pie Plate
Highlights
Materials
100% Pure Ceramic (Clay, Water, Natural Minerals and Oxides)
Est. Price
Anchor Hocking - 9.5" Deep Pie Plate
Highlights
User Satisfaction
Materials
Glass
Est. Price
$16.49
Product Details
- Tempered glass bakeware is microwave, pre-heated oven, refrigerator, freezer, and dishwasher safe
- Bakeware set does not include a lid
- Does not warp, stain, retain smells, or leach chemicals
- Healthier alternative to metal and plastic
- Protected by a limited five-year warranty
- Made in the USA
Pros & Cons
Pros Mentioned
- Durable
- Versatile
- Easy-to-clean
Cons Mentioned
- Breakable
Pyrex - 9.5" Pie Plate
Highlights
User Satisfaction
Materials
Glass
Est. Price
$17.00
Product Details
- great for lasagnas, casseroles, cakes, breads, and cobblers
- safe in the oven, microwave, refrigerator, freezer, and dishwasher
- non-porous glass that won't absorb food odors, flavors, or stains
- clear glass allows you to watch your food as it cooks
- made in the U.S.A.
- durable with good heat conduction for even, consistent baking
- transparent for easy monitoring of baking progress
- introduced 90 years ago and made of a durable, high temperature material
- original glass bakeware
Pros & Cons
Pros Mentioned
- Durable
- Easy-to-clean
- Reliable
Cons Mentioned
- Small
OXO - Glass Pie Plate with Lid
Highlights
User Satisfaction
Materials
Borosilicate Glass
Est. Price
$14.99
Product Details
- Thermal-shock-resistant borosilicate glass can go from the freezer or fridge to the microwave or oven without cracking
- generous rim offers a safe and comfortable grip
- easy-read 9-inch dimension marking
- perfect for pies, quiches, crumbles, and more
- BPA free lid is slosh-proof and protects food when taking to picnics or potlucks
- microwave safe, oven safe, freezer safe, dishwasher safe
- BPA free and PVC free
- OXO better guarantee: repair or replacement in case of issues
Pros & Cons
Pros Mentioned
- Sturdy
- Convenient
- Durable
Cons Mentioned
- Brittle
Staub - Ceramics Pie Dish
Highlights
User Satisfaction
Materials
Ceramic
Est. Price
$39.95
Product Details
```html
- Vitreous glass porcelain-enamel finish
- Highly scratch resistant
- Stoneware will not absorb moisture
- Diffuses heat gently and retains heat exceptionally well
- Transitions from oven to table
- Microwave, freezer, broiler, and oven safe up to 572F
- Dishwasher safe
- Designed by Staub in France, manufactured in China
- Highly impact and thermal shock resistant
```
Pros & Cons
Pros Mentioned
- Beautiful
- Durable
- Functional
Cons Mentioned
- Small
Lodge - Cast Iron Pie Pan
Highlights
User Satisfaction
Materials
Cast Iron
Est. Price
$19.99
Product Details
- Edge-to-edge even heat for bakery-quality results.
- Seasoned with 100% vegetable oil and ready to use out of the box.
- Won’t dent, bend, or warp, ensuring heirloom quality.
- Manufactured in the USA since 1896.
- Excellent heat distribution and retention for consistent baking.
- Design is easy to grip, lift, and move about the kitchen.
Pros & Cons
Pros Mentioned
- Durable
- Even
- Non-stick
Cons Mentioned
- Heavy
Caraway - Nonstick 9" Ceramic Circle Pan
Highlights
User Satisfaction
Materials
Aluminum, Ceramic Nonstick
Est. Price
$60.00
Emile Henry - 9" Pie Dish
Highlights
User Satisfaction
Materials
Ceramic
Est. Price
$43.91
USA Pan - Aluminized Steel Pie Pan
Highlights
User Satisfaction
Materials
Aluminized Steel, Silicone Coating
Est. Price
$15.99
Product Details
- made in the usa
- aluminized steel construction
- commercial grade and heavy gauge
- unique corrugated surface design facilitates air circulation for evenly baked goods and quick release
- coated with americoat - a silicone that is ptfe, pfoa, and bpa free
- patented americoat plus non-stick coating allows for easy clean-up and effortless release
- maximum service life due to even heat distribution and heavy gauge steel construction
- resists warping due to unique fluted surface design
- long-lasting, durable, reliable
- manufactured by a bundy family company for over 50 years in the usa
Pros & Cons
Pros Mentioned
- Durable
- Non-stick
- Even-baking
Cons Mentioned
- Expensive
Mora Ceramic - 9.5" Large Porcelain Baking Dish
Highlights
User Satisfaction
Materials
Porcelain
Est. Price
$23.99
Sweese - 6.5" Mini Pie Pan Set
Highlights
User Satisfaction
Materials
Porcelain
Est. Price
$29.99
Our Product Rating System
First, Camille (co-creator of Welpr) hand picks cleaner product options from a variety of sources.
Next, we collect information about each product's safety, consumer satisfaction, and eco-ethical standing.
Finally, we run all this information through an algorithm that calculates the Welpr Rating.
Welpr Rating:
5.0/5
Part 1: Product safety
We evaluate safety information from 3rd party organizations (e.g. EWG, Made Safe, etc.). Instead of relying solely on any one of these companies for safety information, we assess all of them.
Part 2: Consumer satisfaction
We scour the web for consumer ratings and reviews to verify products are not only cleaner options, but also effective. Products can either be Above Average, Average, or Below average for their respective category (e.g. cleaning products).
Part 3: Ethics & Environment
When you buy a product, you’re supporting that company with your dollars. We believe it’s important to support ethical companies, so we pool together certifications that verify a company's ethics and environmental impact.
Chemical Name
Why it’s harmful
No items found.
About The Author